Josh Hawley Just Asked MLB Executives One Question Rob Manfred Cannot Answer

June 19, 2026 Cat2, Politics
alexkich via shutterstock

MLB punished Giants pitchers for something it paid to put on jerseys in 2020.

Now a U.S. Senator is demanding the receipts.

What Hawley found in the league's own records has Manfred backed into a corner he cannot escape.

MLB's Rule Only Applies to the Bible

Landen Roupp and a teammate wrote Bible verse citations on their hats during the team's Pride Night game against the Cubs on June 12, right next to the rainbow-colored Giants logo.

A third player, Sam Hentges, quietly swapped his Pride Night hat for a regular one.

MLB's response: formal warnings to the two players who wrote the verses.

Sen. Josh Hawley fired off a letter to Commissioner Rob Manfred the next day.

"I write with grave concern over your reported decision to issue a formal warning to three Major League Baseball players for publicly expressing their Christian faith," Hawley wrote.

That concern hardened into something much sharper once Hawley's team started pulling records.

MLB's defense was simple: the league forbids writing of any kind on uniforms.

Hawley shredded that defense in two paragraphs.

In 2020, MLB stitched "Black Lives Matter" and "United for Change" patches onto player jerseys.

It gave teams the option to stencil "BLM" onto pitching mounds.

It lifted its own equipment rules so players could put progressive political slogans on their cleats.

That was not players bending the rules – that was the commissioner's office designing the messages, authorizing them, and broadcasting them to millions of Americans on league broadcasts.

Now Manfred wants the public to believe that Bible verse citations on a hat crossed a line that Black Lives Matter stitched onto a jersey somehow did not.

A Pattern, Not an Incident

This would be easier for MLB to dismiss if it were the first time.

It is not.

Three weeks before the Giants story broke, James O'Keefe's team caught Sean Hudson – the Washington Nationals' Director of Community Relations – on hidden camera admitting he deliberately excluded pitcher Trevor Williams from team social media because Williams is Catholic.

Williams had publicly criticized the Los Angeles Dodgers for hosting the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence – a drag group that performs in nun costumes with crucifixes – at their 2023 Pride Night.

Hudson's response to a player defending his faith: blacklist him from the team's brand.

The Washington Nationals fired Hudson after the tape went public and issued an apology.

The Department of Justice, responding to a letter from Rep. Lauren Boebert, confirmed it is reviewing the situation.

Two MLB organizations.

Two documented cases of Christians punished for their faith.

One league office that approved BLM on the mound and now claims it never allows writing on uniforms.

Hawley is not asking Manfred to take his word for it.

He is asking for the complete text of the uniform regulation used to warn the Giants players, a list of every player warned or punished under that policy in the last five seasons, and documentation of whether players face any consequences for declining to wear Pride Night uniforms.

That last request matters more than it looks.

If MLB has any written policy requiring players to wear Pride Night gear – or penalizing those who don't – the league is not just enforcing a neutral dress code.

It is mandating ideological participation while punishing religious expression.

MLB's Sweetheart Deal Has a Price Tag

Here is what Rob Manfred has never had to worry much about before: Congress.

Major League Baseball is the only professional sports league in America that operates under a federal antitrust exemption – a carve-out rooted in a 1922 Supreme Court ruling that has survived a century of legal challenges because Congress chose not to touch it.

Every other league plays by normal market rules.

MLB does not.

That exemption is why Manfred moved the 2021 All-Star Game out of Atlanta.

It is why he has spent years leaning left without consequences.

But Hawley called the arrangement exactly what it is: "MLB has a sweetheart deal from the federal government. They play by different rules than any other business in America. But now MLB is using its power to target Christians and trample free speech."

Businesses that enjoy special federal protection do not get to run one set of rules for left-wing political speech and a different set for Christians.

Not if Congress starts paying attention.

And Congress just started paying attention.

Sources:

  • Ian Miller and Alexandra Koch, "Senator Josh Hawley demands answers from MLB on 'pattern of discrimination' over warnings to Giants players," OutKick, June 17, 2026.
  • Josh Hawley, "Hawley Demands Answers from MLB for Penalizing Christian Players," hawley.senate.gov, June 17, 2026.
  • "Washington Nationals Under DOJ Investigation for Religious Discrimination," The Liberty Daily / WND, May 30, 2026.
  • "Washington Nationals Executive Admits He Discriminates Against Christian Players," The Daily Caller, May 26, 2026.
  • "MLB to allow BLM, social justice jersey patches," ESPN, July 22, 2020.
  • "MLB players allowed to wear 'Black Lives Matter' patches on jerseys for Opening Day," CBS Sports, July 23, 2020.