Donald Trump spent years calling mail ballots the cheating that stole his election.
His own Supreme Court pick just helped kill his latest fight to stop them.
Amy Coney Barrett sided with the left-wing justices against the president who appointed her.
Barrett Writes the Opinion Trump Didn't See Coming
On Monday, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that states can keep counting mail-in ballots that arrive after Election Day, as long as they were postmarked on time.
Barrett wrote the majority opinion herself.
She was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and the Court's three liberal justices – Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
Justice Samuel Alito wrote the dissent.
He warned the ruling "creates a serious risk of further undermining public confidence in our elections."
https://twitter.com/DefiantLs/status/2071974539869749571?s=20
Trump didn't hold back either, calling the decision a "tremendous loss" on Truth Social and immediately renewing his demand for the SAVE America Act.
Senator Eric Schmitt of Missouri was blunter.
He called it "a shockingly wrong opinion."
RNC Chairman Joe Gruters accused Democrats of letting elections drag on for days after votes are already cast, instead of ending on Election Day like Americans expect.
Why Barrett's Vote Stings More Than the Ruling Itself
This isn't the first time mail ballots have ended up in front of the Supreme Court with the country's future on the line.
Twenty-six years ago, Florida's hanging chads and overseas absentee ballots decided a presidency in Bush v. Gore – a 5-4 decision so explosive the Court tried to bury its own precedent the moment it was written.
Barrett worked that exact fight as a young lawyer in Florida in 2000, helping Republicans get absentee ballots counted for George W. Bush.
Twenty-six years later, she's the deciding vote letting Democrat-friendly mail rules stand instead of striking them down.
https://twitter.com/DefiantLs/status/2071992155522875881?s=20
The math behind Trump's frustration isn't theoretical, either.
Roughly two dozen states currently let ballots trickle in after Election Day.
Washington's Secretary of State admitted more than 250,000 ballots arrived late in 2024 alone – exactly the kind of ballots Trump wanted gone before this November's midterms.
The Bill Trump Wants Now Has No Excuse Left
Trump's answer has been sitting in the Senate since February: the SAVE America Act.
It requires proof of citizenship to register, photo ID to vote, and would gut the mail-in system that just survived the Supreme Court.
It's not a fringe idea.
A Pew Research poll found 83 percent of Americans support requiring photo ID to vote – including 71 percent of self-identified Democrats and 76 percent of Black voters.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune put it plainly, saying the only Americans not to support voter ID requirements are "Democrats here in Congress."
Yet Thune has also told Trump for months that Republicans don't have the 60 votes to break a Democrat filibuster, even with 53 Senate seats.
Chuck Schumer is calling the bill "Jim Crow 2.0." Senator Alex Padilla welcomed the Supreme Court's ruling, saying it should reassure rural and military voters their mail ballots will count this fall.
https://twitter.com/MegynKellyShow/status/2071792243455803817?s=20
That's the same Schumer who has never explained why requiring an ID to vote is somehow more dangerous than requiring one to board a plane.
Some House Republicans now want to force the issue by attaching the SAVE Act to the defense funding bill, daring Democrats to shut down the military over a voter ID law they claim is racist but 76 percent of black voters support.
Trump has had enough of Republicans who won't fight for it.
He told holdout conservatives like Anna Paulina Luna to stop "grandstanding" and get the bill moving.
After Monday, he doesn't have a choice.
The Supreme Court just told Trump that the rules Democrats wrote for 2020 are staying in place for 2026 – unless Congress changes them first.
Sources:
- Joan Biskupic, "Supreme Court upholds grace periods for mail-in ballots," NPR, June 29, 2026.
- Tal Axelrod, "SCOTUS rebuffs GOP bid to block counting of late-arriving mail ballots," ABC News, June 29, 2026.
- Carter Sherman, "Republicans call for Senate to pass SAVE America Act following Supreme Court mail-in ballot ruling," Spectrum News, June 29, 2026.
- "Supreme Court rejects Republican attempt to move up mail ballot deadline," Votebeat, June 29, 2026.
- Stephen Neukam, "Trump says SAVE America Act more important than ever following SCOTUS ruling on mail-in ballots," The Hill, June 29, 2026.
- Brian Schwartz, "Americans support SAVE America Act's photo ID requirement, but Democrats reject it," NBC News, March 17, 2026.